Mathematics
reviews written by Olga Yiparaki,
January 2003
Back in prehistoric
and savage days (3-4 years ago), Palms were merely great organizational devices.
This is no longer an accurate description, they are so much more (assuming
you care to load them with some of the available apps).
There are many
mathematical and scientific applications. I have been looking at as
many as I can find, installing, evaluating, and frequently deleting them
to make room for others. Many are excellent, many are good, and some
are so-so. Here are the ones I consider the very best.
- Easy
Calc. There are scores and scores of scientific calculators for
the Palm OS. Their prices vary from $0 to $50. Easy Calc is one
of the best 2, in my view. It uses color in a very helpful way (when
graphing many functions together, for example). It's a little quirky
in its syntax, but very consistent, and has an incredible collection of built
in functions (e.g., elliptic integrals). It does complex arithmetic, matrix
operations, you name it. It's not RPN, unfortunately. It is fully programmable.
The author is very committed to improving this, getting feedback, responds
quickly to requests and comments, etc. This is excellent all around.
It's free.
- LyME. There are some times
when I stumble upon an application that leaves me with the feeling that I
am stealing something, that I ought to be paying for it -- and I would gladly
pay for it. This is one of them. It is free and fabulous.
Life is good when you have LyME on your Palm. It is basically MATLAB
for your Palm. Does it get much better than this?! Take a look at the
Getting
Started Guide to get a sense of some of what you can do.
- NeoCal.
This is the best RPN calculator that I have found for the Palm. Miss
your trusty old HP? This is great. It is not a graphing calculator,
though. It has a very nice layout, customizable buttons, and some very
nice conversion and time calculation utilities.
- Mtrx
Calc. This is the another good calculator. Very similar
to Easy Calc, but has a more intuitive syntax -- in fact, it uses MATLAB syntax
:-) but is not RPN. Fully programmable. Shareware, $25.
- ProStats
lets you do statistical analysis on data that is imported from a spreadsheet
or directly written by the user. Calculates standard deviations, means,
medians, hypothesis testing and confidence intervals, plots histograms, etc.
Data sets cannot have more than 100 points. Moving from one function
to the next (e.g., from data to plots and back) seemed a little weird to
me at first, but I got used to it. It's a good application.
- There are
many, many more calculator-like applications for the Palm OS. Some
are very specialized (e.g., StairsC
to calculate what is needed for staircase building, and Crickometer which
calculates the temperature by counting chirps from crickets). Others are improvements
on the built-in "scientific" calculator. Let me mention 2 more that
are very good and have gotten a lot of attention. One is MathU
Pro, the other is Power
One Graph. MathU Pro
is very good. It does exactly what it claims, and it is available in
many flavors. All flavors have the same goal: to emulate some HP calculator
on the Visor or Palm device. They even allow you to get the exact look
on the screen (if you have a color device). Yes, this allows you to continue
a geeky love affair with your old calculator. I happen to love my HP
48G calculator, but I think that emulating another product is misguided.
Standalone calculators are one thing, but writing a Palm OS application from
scratch in order to imitate what's already been done in the past is nearsighted.
The Palm OS allows us to do so much more, why limit what you can do?
The better vision is that adopted by the first two calculators above -- they
approach a Visor/Palm device as an extension of a computer and they take
advantage of it.
- The other calculator, Power
One Graph (and the rest of the Power One family) is also very nice but
nearsighted in my opinion. This family of calculators seems to have been
roughly inspired by TI calculators. They offer several versions: the
graphing, scientific, financial, etc. These are all separate apps,
so that's a disadvantage but it's consistent with the idea of TI emulation
(different models for different uses). TI calculators work well but they
are clunky. Power One maintains the constipated clunkiness (for example,
you cannot move seamlessly between an algebraic expression of a function
and its graph). I find this approach limited for the same reasons I
outline above: the Palm OS allows us to do so much more, why imitate products
whose nature is limiting?
Summary
| Name |
Size |
Price |
Rating |
| Easy
Calc |
160 KB |
Free |
calculator extraordinaire! |
| LyME |
680 KB |
Free |
excellent ("MATLAB" clone) |
| Mtrx
Calc |
233 KB |
$25 |
excellent calculator |
| NeoCal |
180 KB |
$17 |
excellent RPN (not graphing) |
| ProStats |
131 KB |
$14 |
great for quick stats |
| MathU
Pro |
145 KB |
$35 |
HP clone (good but why not better?) |
| Power
One Graph |
190 KB |
$50 |
approximate TI clone (good but why not better?) |
email us with comments, app recommendations, etc.
back to the Tucson PUG homepage
last update
Jan 14, 2003